Return to Recent Articles menu
Dunnes strike: workers fightback hampered by a flawed strategy
8 April 2015
The confrontation between retail workers
and the management of Dunnes stores across the Irish state is of great
To understand these constraints we have say what would assure victory for the workers. Dunnes are no pushover and a long-term industrial action, secondary action by other workers and a broad public mobilisation would be necessary.
The main union, Mandate, supported by ICTU, have come up with something much less strenuous.
The one day strike follows a familiar pattern. Rather than the first shot in an industrial campaign, it is a bean counting exercise meant to strengthen the union's hand in further negotiations.
Mandate have also launched a public petition demanding fairness with the same objective.
In addition they have been lobbying the government and have announced with pride that Labour minister Ged Nash will shortly enact stronger legal support for collective bargaining rights.
We see here the basic divergence between the interests of the union bureaucracy and the interests of the workers, legal measures will help to maintain the union dues but it is highly unlikely that they will substantially change working conditions. We should not forget that Dunnes negotiated an agreement with Mandate in 2013, yet workers still found themselves at the mercy of the bosses. When the Mandate leadership speak optimistically about the role of the labour court, all we have to do is recall the history of this institution and it's anti working class bias. The reliance on a Labour minister flies in the face of the role of Labour in government, where they have been to the fore in promoting zero hours and zero wage contracts through the infamous job bridge scheme.
The strategy of the union is to use public support for the Dunnes workers so that management will make some concessions to avoid the reputational damage the dispute has brought.
Outside of this constraint, Dunnes have a lot of leeway. The lessons of the vast majority of recent industrial disputes is that once they disappear into negotiations in a back room the bureaucracy are all too happy to cut a deal that is well short of the workers expectations. The combativity and confidence of the bosses is shown by the fact that the strike day was followed by widespread internal intimidation of the strikers.
It is only when workers organise independently
on their own behalf that we will see substantial change. However there
is now a much greater level of combativity among workers and there will
be many more disputes, many more opportunities to organise.
Return to top of page